Minute repeater model 7  Soone ©Antiquorum

Sound of time: the origins of the minute repeater

In every civilization ringing out the time was an absolute prerogative of civilian or religious institutions. And that is why having a way to do it within smaller confines does have a special meaning for the owner of such a timepiece.

By Vincent Daveau

This privilege also explains, no doubt, why collectors find this complication so captivating. However, when talking about minute repeaters two major questions arise. Firstly, who invented the complication, and, secondly, what prompted watchmakers to create such complex instruments for striking the hours. Here is some food for thought.

Antique Minute Repeater 1800 - 1900 Pocket watch with long chain used for winding the chime. Beautiful mechanism (anonymous): two gongs and a see-through actuating mechanism through the back.

The origins

The most ancient minute repeater we know of until now is a piece produced around 1710 in Friedberg, Germany.

Julien Leroy Montre de Carrosse Around 1750 Julien Leroy Montre de Carrosse: striking watch with an hour hand that indicates the chiming hour. The leather case holding the watch has holes to let the chiming sound be heard.

According to the authors of seminal works in horology, it was the English watchmaker Daniel Quare (1649-1724) who invented the minute repeater. This type of innovation undoubtedly aroused the interest of the elites and prompted the proliferation of further developments. Thomas Mudge (1715-1794) is said to have created an improved version of the minute repeater. He was the apprentice of George Graham and a contemporary of John Harrison, and became famous as the inventor of the lever escapement. Mudge’s minute repeater was a definite improvement, but this highly complicated mechanism was to undergo further refining in the workshop of the great Abraham-Louis Breguet, who developed gongs. Their thinness and location on the edge of the movement, made it possible to reduce the thickness of the cases and therefore give the pieces a perfectly contemporary and fashionable look.

Buty repeater, ca. 1835 Buty repeater, ca. 1835. A typical and well-made timepiece with a visible repeater mechanism, hour star, minute rack and quarter snail.

The voice of power

Many things have been written about the origins of the minute repeater. Most of these stories sound a little folkloric or even far-fetched. Some authors still believe that minute repeater watches were used to tell the time at nightfall before the invention of luminescent hands. This would suggest that they, the writers, are outstanding experts in mechanics but not well-versed in social sciences and the underlying values of the Age of Enlightenment.

Repeater watch by Albert H. Potter & Co Repeater watch by Albert H. Potter & Co, Geneva: a beautiful watch with a hinged cover typical of the end of the 19th century. Quality movement with two hammers and two gongs. Screwed chatons. Chronograph balance fine swan's neck fine adjustment and Breguet overcoil.

These notions are comical and fail to takethe habits of the past into consideration. To begin with, someone who could afford a minute repeater at the time did not sleep as we do nowadays. They would sleep in a half-seated position and their room would normally be bathed in the light of a candle (of wax or tallow, depending on income),  which was placed near the bed. Plus, if there had been no night table or light in the room, the owner of such a precious piece would have been forced to feel about in the dark for the watch and risk breaking it by accident. All that to see a time he or she could hear anyway thanks to the different cartel clocks in the house.

Minute repeater watch with chronograph, perpetual calendar and moon phase Minute repeater watch with chronograph, perpetual calendar and moon phase: a gold timepiece with high complications with a sophisticated and complex movement. The repeater mechanism is placed under the dial, the chronograph mechanism is on the bridge side. Chronometer balance.

No, the interest in minute repeaters is much more rational. These instruments are complicated to manufacture and constitute the  miniaturization of a privilege otherwise reserved for political and religious institutions only. Indeed, the materialization of time and sequencing of days through sound has been the physical expression of civilian or religious power since ancient times. As a result, any means of telling the time using sound is intuitively considered a symbol of power.

Antique repeater watch by Henry Robert in Paris 1830 Antique repeater watch by Henry Robert in Paris: a beautiful timepiece with a central balance. Old-style mainplate with the balance cock on top. Meticulous work with fixed bow over the pusher.

For a long time as well, common knowledge had it that the repeaters were a used by better society as a way to discreetly know the time. This was far from being the case. Watchmakers had in fact developed montres à toc (“dumb” repeater watches), which gave the time by vibrations, or montres à tact for blind people who would use their tactile sense to know the time. Actually, the striking-mechanism – both now and then – had to be audible to most and pleasant to the ear so its owner would want it to be heard by many people, either at a salon or at a game parlor. Back then, the notes could express different things, such as boredom, a certain level of wealth, or the desire to attract attention to oneself. As it turns out, people's motivation to buy this sort of timepiece in the past was not so different from their motivation today.

Soone watch late 1800s Soone watch: grande and petite sonnerie, silence and minute repeater function. A rare watch with a movement characteristic of this type of model. Late 1800s. Swiss made.

Sound appreciation

Sound quality is an almost universal value and when it comes to notes, the ear can almost never accept something that is just an approximate. Hence, it is imperative that the tones be quite rich. A minute repeater is, in fact, much more than just a beautiful mechanical assembly.

What it shares with great musical instruments is the fact of being a work of art whose magic springs from the auditory emotion they produce.

And receive each week a custom selection of articles.

The Ultra-thin Vacheron Constantin Patrimony Contemporaine Calibre 1731

By Vincent DaveauContributor
Vacheron Constantin continues to exhibit its historical skills: the Patrimony Contemporaine Ultra-Plate Calibre 1731 chimes almost by tradition.

Mechanical Wonders of Parmigiani @ La Vieille Russie, New York

By Malik Bahri
Attend a Sandoz collection exhibition, one of the finest old automat & timepiece collections, is like transcending one’s horologic culture.